About us

Our story

Jonathan’s was formed when John Martynk and the Fata brothers decided to open a fine food & spirits restaurant in 1991. Fourteen years later, combining their talents and experience, Luigi and Donna Fata along with their two sons began to operate together, Jonathan’s.

Jonathan’s is considered an Endwell landmark and family tradition. It’s a great place to gather for any occasion. Folks meet at Jonathan’s for a variety of things; from families after a school event to the crew from Endwell Fire, everyone agrees this is the place to be!

We have weekly Karaoke and Live Music! Come down and join our family!

Jonathan's Bar

Daily Lunch Specials


Ham & Cheese Club - $6.90
Turkey Club - $6.90


Philly Steak - $6.90
Chicken Philly - $6.90


Chicken Spiedie Wrap - $6.90
Philly Steak Wrap - $6.90


Grilled Prime Rib - $6.90
Tuna Melt - $5.90


Fish Sandwich - $6.90

Daily Dinner Specials


Spaghetti & Meatball Special (served with salad) - $6.00 (EAT IN ONLY)
Pizza Special - $6.00


Baked Lasagna (served with salad) $6


60 Cent Wings (EAT IN ONLY - ORDERS OF 10)

Jonathan's Menu

Think you don't have time for Jonathan's Fine Food? Ever think about taking it To Go?

Jonathan’s Take Out menu offers all of your favorites to go! It is perfect for game time munchies, that romantic night in or family dinner – just leave the cooking to us! Catering for larger parties also available.

Click Here for our takeout menu


Check out our NEW banquet room! The perfect place for family reunions, showers, birthdays, bereavements, business meetings and so much more. The Fireplace Room is also available for private parties. Or you can book both! We can accommodate parties of up to 90 guests.

Our Italian and American banquet menu selection will please the palates of your guests.

Looking for a little more space? Let us assist you at Atrio Banquets & Catering.

Jonathan’s is known for its’ great food and exceptional service. Our family would be proud to serve you and yours. We look forward to assisting you with your banquet or party needs.

Contact Jonathan’s today to learn how we can put our restaurant experience of over 40 years to work for you!

Jonathan's Bar

Dinner Buffet

  • Salad Bar, Bread, Coffee, and Tea
  • Roast Beef with Gravy
  • Baked Ziti
  • Meatballs with Sauce
  • Cut Green Beans and


Your Choice of the following:

  • Chicken Cutlet
  • Chicken Parmesan
  • Chicken Marsala
  • Chicken Picatta
  • Just $16.95 per person plus tax and service charge
  • Lunch Buffet is also available! Just $13.50 per person! 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. Monday thru Friday

Cocktail Party

Pizza, Fresh Veggies and dip, Cheese & Crackers. Choice of 4: Wings, Breaded Mushrooms, Cauliflower, Fried Zucchini Sticks, or Stir Fried Kielbasi. Just $11.00 per person plus tax and service charge


Add ons $2.00 per person per item:

  • Garden Salad
  • Mini BBQ Franks
  • Mini Egg-rolls
  • Chicken Fingers
  • Swedish Meatballs
  • Stir Fried Kielbasi

Drink Options

  • Cash Bar
  • Draft Beer, Wine, and Soda Package $3.00 per hour per person
  • Open Bar $4.50 per hour per person
  • Drink packages have a 3 hour minimum
  • $1.00 per person charge for linen

Our advertised pricing is for those customers paying by check or with cash. Customers paying with a major credit card should add 3%. New York State requires us to collect sales tax. Please add 8%. A gratuity/service charge of 18% will also be added calculated on the Total Check. There is a $1.00 per person charge for linen. We require a guarantee of attendance. Our charges are calculated on the final guarantee count or the actual guest attendance whichever is larger. All advertised prices subject to change. Menus are subject to change depending on availability of products from our suppliers